Custom Order Cookie Box

For those who have already picked their favorites. This is your chance to pick exactly which cookies you want. 

Step 1: Pick how many cookies you want (6 Pack or 1 Dozen)

Step 2: Select which flavors. Pick up to 3 flavors.

🚚 Order within the next 2 hours, 15 minutes for delivery by 19 Jul, 2024.

Craving cookies now and live near Franklin, TN? Order local pickup from our retail store!


See the ingredient list on the individual cookie flavor product pages.

We don't load our cookies with preservatives, but we do individually heat seal them to ensure they are good for up to two weeks. For that right out of the oven experience, warm in the microwave for a few seconds or in the oven at 350 degrees F for 2 to 3 minutes or until warm.

To preserve their freshness, if you don't think you'll consume some of your cookies within two weeks Chef Whitney recommends freezing them in their package or placed in a freezer zip top bag. They'll stay good for up to 4 months and when you're ready to enjoy them, just allow the cookies to thaw and then warm in the microwave for a few seconds or a 350 degrees F oven for about 2 to 3 minutes or until warm.

We ship orders Monday through Friday but we always attempt to maximize freshness and reduce the amount of time they may sit with the shipping carrier! We ship via UPS or USPS Priority for delivery usually within 2 to 3 days.

All of our cookies are individually packaged, sealed, labeled, and boxed with crinkle paper and bubble wrap for protection.

Once your order is shipped, you will receive a confirmation email with tracking information.

Customer Reviews

Based on 90 reviews
Matt DePaepe
Great cookies with very fast shipping

The peach cobbler cookie is my favorite cookie and it's not close! All the cookies have been very good!

Sara S.
Delicious cookies!

I ordered the custom cookie box to take advantage of some monthly flavors, as well as the stuffed chocolate chip cookie. Oh my goodness, these cookies are delicious! I intended on just eating half at one time, but they were too good to stop at just half :)

So good!

I LOVED the stuffed chocolate chip cookies, but wasn’t too crazy about the brownie ones (too rich for me) and the salted peanut butter (not soft enough) as well. I think people would really enjoy these though.


Delicious, you can freeze them and they thaw very quick. If you do not freeze them, you can put them in the microwave for six seconds and it will refresh them.

Stephanie Evans
Too sweet

Too sweet