Our cookie subscription is the perfect way to treat yourself, or someone else!
- OR -
Subscribe to our newsletter for limited-release cookie drops and exclusive offers!
Let customers speak for us
from 502 reviewsThese cookies were absolutely AMAZING ! I was gifted a box for the Holidays and I have enjoyed every flavor in the assorted box. WOW, truly amazing
I ordered these cookies for my 84 year old Mom in Massachusetts. She loves anything apple cider, so when I saw these cookies I had to order them! My Mom loved them and the apple cider flavor was the first one she ate from a variety box! I’ve ordered from Whitney’s cookies before and we are always very pleased!!
This cookie must contain an entire stick of butter, it is so rich. Maybe an entire chocolate bar as well. I rarely finish the whole cookie. A decadent treat.
My husband wants one of these every night!! They are spectacular! Please keep them in your selection category! We will be a loyal customer! And fat and happy ones! lol
Oatmeal raisin cookies are never one of my favorite cookies. I prefer chocolate chip. However, when we purchased the assorted box, THIS was everyone’s favorite! Amazing cookie!
Very rich and natural taste. A chocolate lovers dream
I warm up a half of a cinnamon roll cookie for several seconds in microwave before adding the icing. Yum! And eat the other half another day. Happy a portion of sales goes to a kids church camp!
Grab collab! It's a very unique cookie that lived up to the expectations and they were high! They are one of my favorites, now.
These were so good! The sourdough was a perfect offset of the sweet cinnamon roll. Would definitely order again!
Soooo delicious....I will buy again...._recommend to anyone who love's cookies! Each one is special with new flavors every month! Thank you Whitney's Cookies for great service also!
Tried one out as soon as they arrived! Warmed up in the microwave and it was perfect!! Moist cookie crust, with that ooey-gooey center was irresistible!! Definitely ordering more! Can’t wait to try other flavors!!
The cookies were excellent and had great flavor! I will definitely order from them again.
I will be ordering more of Whitney’s cookies! I thoroughly enjoyed every one of them with my family! 🥰
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Sadie’s sourdough cinnamon roll cookies made by Whitney are absolutely divine! The balance of cinnamon and that hint of tang from the sourdough makes each bite irresistible. Perfectly soft and chewy, they have just the perfect amount of sweetness. It’s clear a lot of love and care goes into their baking and shipping. Definitely a treat I’ll be ordering again – highly recommend!